2502 February 27 HPC102 West Main Street \ Prattville, AL 36067 \ 334. 595.0500 \ prattvilleal.gov
BILL GILLESPIE, JR.
MAYOR
J.SCOTT STEPHENS, AICPDIRECTOR
CITY OF PRATTVILLE
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION AGENDA LOCATION: 124 W Main Street-2nd floor February 27, 2025 4:30 p.m.
Call to Order:
Roll Call: Chairman Miller, Vice-Chairman Pruett, Mr. Ferguson, Ms. Fritz, Ms. Irvine, Mr. McKay, and Ms. Rollins.
Minutes: January 23, 2025
Committee Reports:
Old Business: None
New Business: 1.COA2502-01 Certificate of AppropriatenessAlterations & Rehabilitation 219 S Northington Street Jennifer Davis, Petitioner
Public Hearing
Miscellaneous:
Expedited Review:
Bylaws Review:
Election of Officers:
Adjourn:
PETITIONER:
REQUEST:
PRATTVILLE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSIONCERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
JENNIFER DA VIS
1212 KINGSTON GARDEN ROAD
PRATTVILLE, AL 36067
ALTERATIONS & REHABILITATION
219 S NORTHINGTON STREET
ORDER
2502-01
The above petition having been duly considered at a public hearing meeting before the Historic
Preservation Commission of the City of Prattville, and giving notice that a public hearing would be held
on February 27, 2025 at the City Hall in Prattville, Alabama, and after due consideration of the party in
interest, the Historic Preservation Commission of the City of Prattville voted to approve the certificateof appropriateness at property requested above for:
Item # 1: Windows -approved as submitted with a caveat that it is a simple double hung no grids. Item #2: Doors -approved as submitted. Item #3: Porch and deck-approved as submitted with a caveat that it has posts instead of columns and to approve the changing of the roof to be a simple shed roof Item# 4: Demo of the side entrance awning & stairs-approved as submitted. Item #5: New driveway & walkway -approved as submitted with the option to widen the driveway to allow available passing in the rear. Item #6: Accessory structure -approved as submitted with a gable roojline and in simple design. Item #7: Painting-approved as submitted. Item #8: New lighting -approved as submitted.
DONE THIS THE 27TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
TOM MILLER, CHAIRMAN
�� �0SHUAEY,ACTING SECRETARY
Page 1 of 10
Historic Preservation Commission
Staff Report
CERTIFICATE OF
APPROPRIATENESS
219 South Northington – COA2506-02
DATE
February 27, 2025
PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
Petitioner: Jennifer Davis
Property Owner: Hope Consulting, LLC
Location: 219 South Northington
Review Status and History
Previous
Approvals:
N/A
1984/2007
Historic Properties
Inventory Details
N/A
Proposed Alteration, Renovation or Addition
The following changes have been requested by the applicant.
1. Windows
2. Doors
3. Porch & Deck
4. Demo
5. Driveway & Walkway
6. Accessory Structure
7. Paint
Page 2 of 10
8. Lighting
PLANNING STAFF EVALUATION:
Reviewed by: Bria Hudson, City Planner
Site Visits Conducted: February 2025
Item #1. Windows
Design Guidelines section referenced:
Windows (pp30)
1. Historic windows and their frames shall be retained and maintained.
2. Damaged or deteriorated windows shall be repaired before they are replaced.
3. Historic window openings shall remain visible and shall not be obscured from view through paint,
wood, or other materials and methods which may alter their transparency or appearance.
4. Stained glass and other decorative window elements shall be retained and maintained. Do not
introduce these decorative window elements where there is no historical basis for them.
5. New and replacement windows shall be of a compatible style, configuration, and material of the
historic windows found on the structure.
a. Contemporary materials such as vinyl and other high gloss materials are generally discouraged.
b. Reflective glass windows are generally discouraged.
c. When replacement windows of the same original material cannot be found, the replacement window
shall be of a compatible size, type, configuration, material, appearance and form as the original
windows.
d. Replacement windows shall match the appearance of the original window to the greatest extent
possible. If the structure has no distinctive style, then window configuration and style shall be of a
simple, compatible style with surrounding structures.
Page 3 of 10
e. Replacement windows shall make use of the existing window frame, it shall not be appropriate to
remove the historic framing of window openings.
f. For replacement windows on tertiary building faces that are not easily visible from the right of way,
materials such as vinyl and reflective glass may be considered on a case-by-case basis.
6. The addition of window openings to tertiary faces may be considered on a case-by-case basis if they
do not damage or detract from the integrity of the structure.
Item #1 Staff Evaluation: Approve
The applicant is proposing to replace all 15 windows due to their deteriorated condition and the lack of
a consistent design throughout the structure. Additionally, the applicant is requesting to remove the siding covering a previously enclosed window to restore it to its original state. They are also seeking approval to widen the opening of the kitchen window.
Item #2.Doors
Entrances and Doors (pp 33)
1. Historic doors and entryways shall be retained and maintained.
2. Features such as transoms, sidelights, and molding are defining features of entrances and
shall be retained and maintained.
3. Replacement doors and entryway features shall replicate the original features as much as
possible in appearance and design.
4. Openings and entrances that were not historically present shall not be added to existing
structures.
5. An entrance or doorway may be added to an existing historic structure if there is evidence of
an entrance or doorway existing there historically.
a. When an entrance or doorway is to be added, it shall be of a compatible material and design to
the structure’s historic architectural style. If the structure has no distinctive style, then a style
compatible with the district’s character shall be used.
b. New exterior entries to tertiary building faces or to non-historic structures may be appropriate
and shall be considered on a case-by-case basis.
6. Wood is the most appropriate material for replacement doors.
a. Materials such as aluminum and metal shall not be permitted unless there is evidence of the
material historically being used on the structure.
b. Other materials may be considered on a case-by-case basis if the entry door is not visible from
the right of way and if it does not detract from the integrity of the historic structure.
Page 4 of 10
7. Screen and storm doors shall be compatible with the style of the structure, have a wood frame,
and not block visibility of historic doors and entryways.
8. Security doors shall not be added to primary and secondary building faces. c. Similar window
locations and window proportions.
d. Similar façade and entry elements such as storefronts.
e. Similar roof forms.
Item #2 Staff Evaluation: Approve
The applicant is proposing to restore the entrance door to its original state and install a glass window
in the currently boarded-up opening. They also intend to sand down the door and apply a clear coat
for preservation. Additionally, the applicant is requesting to cover the non-historic side door with vinyl
siding and renovate the boarded-up back door to its original condition.
Item # 3.Porch & Deck
Decks & Porch (pp 29)
1. Decks shall be located at the side or rear of a structure and not be visible from the right of way.
2. Deck additions shall be constructed of a compatible material to the main structure.
3. Composite materials are appropriate for new or replacement decks that are shielded from the right
of way.
4. Deck additions shall be of a compatible size and scale and shall not overshadow the main
structure.
5. Fencing and landscaping can block visibility of a deck addition if it does not detract from the
integrity of the building.
Porches
1. Porches are often a defining feature of many historic structures and shall be maintained and
retained.
2. Architectural elements of porches shall be maintained and retained.
3. In the case of damage or deterioration of historic porch elements, in-kind replacement of existing
elements shall be taken before wholesale removal and replacement. Replacement materials shall be
compatible with the existing porch.
4. Alterations to porches shall not be appropriate when the alterations obscure or destroy defining
features of the main structure.
a. The enclosing of porches visible from the right of way is prohibited.
Page 5 of 10
b. Porches may be screened if the alteration makes use of minimal structure changes and maintains
an open appearance.
c. On a case-by-case basis, rear porches may be enclosed if they are not easily visible from the right
of way, and if they do not detract from the integrity of the historic structure or damage historic
materials.
5. New porches shall be oriented to be compatible with other porches along the block; in most
instances porches will be oriented towards the street.
6. Porch shape, size, scale, form, and design shall be compatible with what was historically found
within the structure’s architectural style. If the structure has no distinctive style, then a style
compatible with the district’s character shall be used.
7. New and replacement porches shall be constructed of materials compatible with the building to
which they are attached.
Item #3 Staff Evaluation: Approve
The applicant is requesting to renovate and expand the front porch, incorporating brick stairs, columns, and composite plank decking extending perpendicular to South Northington Street. The
proposed porch would align flush with the right-side extension of the house and extend to the left
edge, measuring approximately 7' x 22.3'. Please note that the front porch was not part of the original structure and is considered non-historic. Additionally, the applicant is proposing a rear deck addition that will be attached at the back entrance
of the structure. Currently, the back entrance is boarded up and inaccessible. The deck will be
constructed using Trex decking, consistent with the proposed front porch materials, and will include stairs with a railing leading up to the deck and entrance. Item #4. Demo
Demolition Guidelines (pp 63)
1. The demolition of contributing historic structures within the Prattville Historic District is strongly
discouraged and should only be pursued as a last resort.
2. The demolition of non-contributing structures within the historic district may be appropriate, though the
applicant should provide information on future plans for the property to avoid vacant, empty lots within
the historic district.
3. For contributing historic structures, the applicant shall explore other possibilities such as selling the
structure, incorporating the structure into a new build, or relocating the structure to another lot within the
historic district.
4. The applicant is encouraged to work with the HPC to explore other alternatives.
5. In the event of the demolition of a historic structure, the applicant shall record historic structures on
site either through photographs or architectural drawings to be kept with the City of Prattville.
6. In the event of a demolition, the applicant shall make the following efforts in coordination with the HPC
and City Staff:
Page 6 of 10
a. Reuse of salvageable materials and architectural materials or features.
b. Preserve any historic vegetation or landscaping on site for future use and development, unless the
removal of such features is unavoidable or their retention presents a hazard.
c. Ensure the safety of adjacent structures during the demolition process.
Item #4 Staff Evaluation: Approve
The applicant is proposing to demolish the existing awning and stairs at the side entrance, as they
also plan to cover the entrance with vinyl siding. Please note that this side entrance is a non-historic
addition and was not part of the original structure.
Staff Recommendation: Approve; the proposed changes use appropriate materials, scale, and draw
inspiration from the historical industrial structures and activities that existed on the site.
Item #5. Driveway & Walkway Driveways and Sidewalks (pp 22)
1. Historic driveways and sidewalks shall be retained and maintained.
2. New driveways shall not damage or destroy important landscaping features and shall be oriented to
be compatible with the overall streetscape of the block.
3. New driveways shall be of a similar size and scale to what is found nearby within the historic district.
4. New driveways shall make use of existing curbcuts when possible. Avoid new curbcuts unless they
are necessary for driveway access. New curbcuts shall match historic curbcuts along the street in size,
profile, and configuration.
5. Driveways shall be located to the side of the main structure when possible. Unique or unusually
shaped lots may warrant a driveway in a different location, though the applicant shall make a best faith
effort to incorporate a driveway that is compatible with the streetscape.
6. Driveways shall be constructed of materials typically found within the historic district such as gravel,
concrete ribbons, pavers, dirt, and concrete.
7. Larger driveways may be appropriate if they are located in the rear of the lot.
8. Materials such as blacktop and asphalt were not historically found within the residential part of the
historic district and are prohibited.
9. New sidewalks and walkways shall follow historical trends set by the historic district. Many residential
buildings have narrow concrete walkways leading from the sidewalk to the building entrance;
construction of new walkways shall follow this historical precedent.
Streetscape (pp 24)
1. Historic elements of the streetscape such as lighting, sidewalks, landscaping, retaining walls, and
other elements which may add to the historic character of the block shall be retained and maintained.
Page 7 of 10
2. Alterations to streetscape elements shall be compatible with neighboring blocks and the overall
character of the historic district.
3. Alterations to the streetscape that create a false sense of history, or detract from the character of the
historic district shall be prohibited.
Item #5 Staff Evaluation: Approve
The applicant is proposing to install a circular driveway featuring a running bond design, using red
rock pavers with burnt umber accents. The proposed driveway will have entry points on both the
porch side and the south side of the structure.
Additionally, the applicant is proposing a brick walkway leading up to the front porch, using the same
color scheme and materials. They intend to repurpose existing bricks from the interior of the structure
for this project.
Please note that the applicant is actively coordinating with the City Engineer to address any concerns
related to the existing site conditions.
Item #6. Accessory Structure
Accessory Structure (pp 38-39)
New Accessory Structures
1. New accessory structures that are visible from the right of way shall be compatible with the style of the
main structure.
2. New accessory structures shall be subordinate to the main structure.
3. New accessory structures shall be constructed of materials similar in pattern, texture, and appearance
to the main structure.
4. Pre-fabricated accessory structures such as tool and storage sheds may be appropriate if they are
shielded from the right of way.
5. Storm shelters shall not be visible from the right of way, or shall be made to have a style that is
compatible with the style of the main structure.
6. On properties with alleyway access, locate new garages along the alleyway when feasible.
Item #6 Staff Evaluation: Approve
The applicant is proposing to install an accessory structure on the existing concrete pad, located
toward the rear side of the structure at the end of the proposed driveway on the left side. The shed
will be built to match the dimensions of the existing concrete pad, which measures 8' x 20'.
Page 8 of 10
Item #7. Paint Painting (pp 32)
1. Painting of existing painted surfaces is an important facet of maintaining the integrity of the material
and is encouraged.
2. Historically unpainted features and surfaces should remain unpainted.
3. In the case where a surface is mismatched or damaged, paint may be used to conceal the defect or
maintain the surface.
Item #7 Staff Evaluation: Approve
The applicant is proposing to paint the existing vinyl siding to address areas of rust and discoloration,
using a color scheme consistent with the rest of the structure.
Item #8. Lighting
Lighting (pp 29-30)
1. Historic lighting fixtures shall be retained and maintained.
2. Repair damaged or deteriorated lighting fixtures to maintain their appearance.
3. The addition of lighting fixtures may be appropriate if the addition does not detract from or obscure the
historic integrity of the structure.
4. When replacement of historic lighting fixtures is necessary, the replacement fixtures shall be of a
compatible style, appearance, and material design to what was historically found in the subject
structure’s architectural style.
a. New lighting shall make use of existing mounting locations when feasible.
b. New lighting shall avoid damaging the subject historic structure and its elements.
Item #8 Staff Evaluation: Approve
The applicant is proposing to install lighting fixtures at both the front and back entrances, as well as a
lamp post along the walkway leading to the front porch.
Staff Recommendation: Approve
Current/Existing Site:
Page 9 of 10
Page 10 of 10
216
234232
237
230
239
222
219
213
328
218
226
202
234
214
228
S N
O
R
T
H
I
N
G
T
O
N
S
T
Maxar, Microsoft
Legend
Project Area
Prattville City Limits
Autauga Parcels
0 10050
Feet
Locations are approximate ±
Aerial Map
371
131
310
209
302330326
324 306307
301 318314302
225
320
325
323
216
234232
215
344
256244
321
325
410
327321
309
307
402364
333
328
336335
323
315
237
230
347 369
407
238
241 255 263
271 250
239
334
322
272232
327
319
311
249
237
217 231
321
221222219
213
324 328
218
226231
221
240 202
220
230
227
221
213
205
232
129
127
427
191
181
171
161
345
250
218
180
418 424
245
326
320
325
316
234
228
370
E MAIN ST
E 3RD ST
S W
A
S
H
I
N
G
T
O
N
S
T
S N
O
R
T
H
I
N
G
T
O
N
S
T
MO
N
C
R
I
E
F
S
T
CO
L
L
E
G
E
S
T
PR
A
T
T
S
T
Maxar, Microsoft
Legend
Project Area
Prattville City Limits
Autauga Parcels
0 400200
Feet
Locations are approximate ±
Location Map
371
131
310
209
302330326
324 306307
301 318314302
225
320
325
323
216
234232
215
344
256244
321
325
410
327321
309
307
402364
333
328
336335
323
315
237
230
347 369
407
238
241 255 263
271 250
239
334
322
272232
327
319
311
249
237
217 231
321
221222219
213
324 328
218
226231
221
240 202
220
230
227
221
213
205
232
129
127
427
191
181
171
161
345
250
218
180
418 424
245
326
320
325
316
234
228
370
R-2
R-3
B-2
Downtown Overlay
R-3
B-2
B-2
B-2
O-1
R-6
O-1
E MAIN ST
E 3RD ST
S
W
A
S
H
I
N
G
T
O
N
S
T
S N
O
R
T
H
I
N
G
T
O
N
S
T
MO
N
C
R
I
E
F
S
T
CO
L
L
E
G
E
S
T
PR
A
T
T
S
T
Maxar, Microsoft
Legend
Project Area
Prattville City Limits
Autauga Parcels
Zoning
Downtown Overlay
B-1
B-2
B-3
B-4
F.A.R.
M-1
M-2
O-1
P.U.D.
INST
R-1
R-2
R-3
R-4
R-5
R-6
RD-1
T-1
T-2
T-3
0 400200
Feet
Locations are approximate ±
Zoning Map
Windows
Metal storm windows with screens were installed by the previous owner, and we would like to replace to
windows with vinyl no grid or SDL exterior to restore a more original look and to have a consistent grid
pattern throughout the house.
Example of windows installed by A&M Windows in the historic district of Montgomery
West side Living room window – no existing weights, does not open, no grid, no easy access to replace
weight
North side Living Room window – no existing weights, does not open, no grid, no easy access to replace
weight
Dining Room window 1 – has one weight, does not open, has grid, no easy access to replace weight
Dining Room window 2 – no weights, does not open, has grid, no easy access to replace weight, severely
damaged framing
Den South Facing Window – has both weights, opens, frame deteriorated, won’t open, mix of grids and
no grids, no easy access to replace weight
Existing front bedroom windows – no grids, broken glass, won’t open, no easy access to replace weight,
only three out of four weights
Window on south side of front room – Frame falling apart, only one weight, cannot open, no easy access
for replacing weights and string
South side facing windows to replace – Has both weights, opens, no easy access to replace weights or
string, no grids, glass cracked
Interior from of bathroom window – replace with original size and trim
Windows on the back side of the house tertiary to the street to replace – all metal and rusted, want to
replace with similar looking windows to the rest of the house
Kitchen window – can we enlarge the opening?
Laundry room window
Den window
New Window in Existing Opening
Interior cutout of where there once was a window in the den on the south side
Front Door: Glass – clear and beveled along the outer edges. Door: Sanded with a clear coat of
sealant
Existing door
Porch Light, Lampost, House Numbers, Mailbox
Not sure if we need approval for these, but below are examples of what we would like to use as lights,
house numbers, a lamp post, and mailbox.
Front Porch and Walkway –
This is the style we would like to replicate with the brick stairs, white columns, and plank decking with
composite like Trex running perpendicular to the road
We would like to use more weather resistant plank like Trex as seen in this downtown
home.
With the color matching this
This is the current porch not original to the house.
Entire front of the house. The porch would be flush with the right extension of the house and wide to be
flush with the left edge of the house approximately 7’x22.3’.
This is an example of the brick walkway we would like to replicate leading up to the porch possibly
utilizing existing brick inside the house from removing a chimney that was already halfway removed
previously.
Side Door – wall off non-historic side door, demo non-historic patio and awning, and match current
siding and concrete blocks
Back Deck – same color Trex as front porch, steps with railing, light, gutter system, and door
Existing back door
z
Driveway – Circular with Running Bond design as pictured (other options - 45 Degree Running
Bond, 45 Degree Herring Bone, 90 Degree Herring Bone)
Aspire Pavers – Redrock with Burnt Umber accents
Driveway entry north side and south side of house
Shed – on existing concrete pad pad 8’x20’
Painting
Concrete Block Foundation White all the way around
Touch up painting the siding as needed